First Edition Points and Criteria for To Kill a Mockingbird

Year Published: 1960
Author Last Name: Lee
Author First Name: Harper
Publisher: Lippincott
Original Price: $3.95
Pages: 296

This book is in high demand. Approximately 5,000 first printings were produced. "FIRST EDITION" is stated on the copyright page. Boards are brown with green cloth spine.

A first edition dust jacket has no statement of printing and has a price of $3.95 on the lower corner of the front flap. There appears to be two states of the first edition dust jacket. One state has two reviews on the back flap - by Shirley Ann Grau and Phyllis McGinley. We have seen only one of these. The other state dust jacket has a single Jonathan Daniels review, and we have seen many of these. Both states have the Capote blurb in green, the $3.95 price, and no printing statement on the front flap. They both have the author's photo on the back panel. They are identical except for the back flap reviews.

There has been significant debate about the order of the states. The case for the Grau/McGinley state being first is that the Grau and McGinley reviews were replaced by the Daniels blurb on the stated second printing of the dust jacket. Also, an early advertisement establishes that Grau and McGinley read advance copies and "poured out their enthusiasm... weeks before publication of the book". The case for the Daniels state being first is that normally blurbs for a first book progress from obscure reviewers to more famous ones as a book becomes more popular. So it raises questions of the why the publisher would change blurbs from two well known authors to one lesser known minister. This is supported by the fact that the Grau review returns to the back flap, and the McGinley review to the front flap of the seventh printing.

The Jonathan Daniels who wrote the dust jacket review was not Jonathan Myrick Daniels, the Episcopal seminarian killed for his civil rights work in 1965. Rather, the review was written by Jonathan Worth Daniels, who at the time was the editor of the Raleigh News and Observer. Jonathan Worth Daniels was an author and an outspoken supporter of civil rights. He also served as press secretary for Franklin D. Roosevelt and Harry S. Truman. Jonathan Worth Daniels was hardly obscure.

While the stated second printing dust jackets have the Daniels review, we have found that the stated third printing jackets have the Grau/McGinley reviews.

In 1960, To Kill a Mockingbird was issued by at least four book clubs. One of these was the Book-of-the-Month Club (BOMC), which differs from other book clubs by producing books of the same quality and design as the trade editions. BOMC issues of Mockingbird have the same green cloth backing and brown-papered boards as the trade editions, but the well-known BOMC indentation is added to the back cover. The BOMC does NOT have the Capote photograph of Lee on the rear panel. Earlier book club editions (BCEs) do have the desired photograph on the rear panel, but the books are thinner and of cheaper material and of at least three different cover designs.

The first edition does not have a "W" on the copyright page. However, many people write and ask what the "W" means on their later printing copies. We cannot support the common thought that it is a book club indicator. Although we certainly have seen it on BOMC editions, we have also consistently found it on the seventh through thirteenth printings of the genuine Lippincott trade editions (priced dust jackets and no book club indicators). Consequently the presence of the "W" is not an accurate indicator of the BOMC or any other book club edition. So what does the "W" mean? We don't know. We have never seen it on the first through sixth printings, nor have we seen it on the fourteenth through twenty-first printings. One possible explanation is that is a printing-plant indicator.

Signed first printings of the first edition command the highest value. But unsigned first printings are extremely valuable as well. Second printings are very rare and have high value. Book club and anniversary copies are common.

To Kill a Mockingbird won the Pulitzer Prize for Fiction. This book is also one of Time Magazine's 100 Best Novels. Other Time 100 Novels include The Assistant and Catch-22

Picture of the 1960 first edition dust jacket for To Kill a Mockingbird.
Picture of the 1960 first edition dust jacket for To Kill a Mockingbird.

"FIRST EDITION" is stated.
"FIRST EDITION" is stated.

Early printings had Harper Lee's photograph on the back.  Later printings have
Early printings had Harper Lee's photograph on the back. Later printings have reviews on the back.

The first printing of the dust jacket had a price of $3.95 on the bottom of the front
The first printing of the dust jacket had a price of $3.95 on the bottom of the front flap with no printing statement.

later printings are stated on the bottom of the front dust jacket flap as is the case
later printings are stated on the bottom of the front dust jacket flap as is the case with this second printing jacket. Book club jackets did not state printing, nor did they state price. So even thought the price on this jacket is clipped, we know it is not a book club jacket because it states the printing.

First, second, and at least third printing dust jackets have a Truman Capote quote in
First, second, and at least third printing dust jackets have a Truman Capote quote in green ink on the front flap.

The Grau/McGinley state dust jacket has reviews by Shirley Ann Grau and Phyllis McGinley
The Grau/McGinley state dust jacket has reviews by Shirley Ann Grau and Phyllis McGinley on the back flap.

The Daniels state has the Jonathan Daniels blurb on the rear flap.
The Daniels state has the Jonathan Daniels blurb on the rear flap.

Boards are brown with green cloth spine cover.
Boards are brown with green cloth spine cover.

Identification picture of To Kill a Mockingbird.

Caution: the presence of the FEL logo on the bottom back flap indicates that this is a
Caution: the presence of the FEL logo on the bottom back flap indicates that this is a facsimile dust jacket produced by the First Editions Library of Shelton, CT. Beware of a jacket that has damage in this area which may indicate that someone removed the logo.

There are two variants of the advance reading copy of To Kill A Mockingbird.  The variant
There are two variants of the advance reading copy of To Kill A Mockingbird. The variant on the left says that the novel "will be published in July", and the variant on the right (photo courtesy of Ernestoic Books) states specifically that it is "to be published July 11, 1960". The more precise publishing reference on the variant on the right suggests that it was issued after the variant on the left.

The first edition binding of To Kill a Mockingbird on the top with its green spine is
The first edition binding of To Kill a Mockingbird on the top with its green spine is very different than the book club edition below it with a black spine.



Other first edition points for books by Harper Lee include: Go Set a Watchman, Go Set a Watchman (UK).

\"Go \"Go 

Quick Search:

Search for other books in the FedPo database:

Book:



Market Value:

Use the pre-filled links below to find the market value of To Kill a Mockingbird. Remember that the dust jacket is an important part of any book, and so books without their original dust jackets typically have less value.

Book:


Abe Books, Passion for Books
Author:

Title:

Keywords:







Find Books, Save Up To 90% Alibris



Search by author:

by Title:

by Keyword or ISBN:









Popular on FEdPo:


Jaws  The Old Man and the Sea  In Cold Blood  Slaughterhouse-Five  Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone (U.S.)  The Catcher in the Rye  To Kill a Mockingbird  Moby Dick (Illustrated by Rockwell Kent)  East of Eden  A Brief History of Time  The Hunt for Red October  Gone with the Wind  Silent Spring  The Thorn Birds  Of Mice And Men  Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil  All the Pretty Horses  Out of Africa  Catch-22  Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farms  The Pearl  The Manchurian Candidate  Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (U.S.)  The Double Helix  Profiles In Courage  The Godfather  The Grapes of Wrath  The Color Purple  So Big  Outlander  Beloved  A Confederacy of Dunces  The Caine Mutiny  The Magnificent Ambersons  For Whom the Bell Tolls  Tales of the South Pacific  The Great Gatsby  The Moon is Down  Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (U.S.)  Tortilla Flat  Guard of Honor  Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone  Patriot Games  The Bridge of San Luis Rey  From Here to Eternity  A Good Scent From a Strange Mountain  The Stone Diaries  Lonesome Dove  Alice Adams  The Firm  The Complete Stories  Twilight  Death in the Afternoon  The Yearling  Dragon's Teeth  Foreign Affairs  American Pastoral  The Hours  The Road  Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban  Snow Crash  A Lost Lady  The Sympathizer  Cannery Row  Early Autumn  Independence Day  The Collected Stories of Katherine Anne Porter (U.S.)  Dog Soldiers  Charming Billy  All the King's Men  The Da Vinci Code  The Late George Apley  The Good Earth  The mambo kings play songs of love: a novel  His Family  The Corrections  A Separate Peace (U.S.)  Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince (U.S.)  Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix (U.S.)  Tinkers  World's Fair  Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix  Cold Mountain  The Lovely Bones  The Confessions of Nat Turner  The Reivers  Scarlet Sister Mary  The Keepers of the House  One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest  Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (U.S.)  A Farewell to Arms  The Amityville Horror  Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (U.S.)  Child of God  New Moon  The Spectator Bird  The Exorcist  God and Man at Yale  The Goldfinch  The Hunger Games  The Natural  The Winter of Our Discontent  

Disclaimer: This website is intended to help guide you and give you insight into what to look for when identifying first editions. The information is compiled from the experience of reputable collectors and dealers in the industry. Gathering and updating information about these books is more an art than a science, and new identication criteria and points of issue are sometimes discovered that may contradict currently accepted identification points. This means that the information presented here may not always be 100% accurate.